If you bought or refinanced your home a few years ago, two things are probably true. Your home is worth a lot more than you paid. And your mortgage rate is lower than anything you’ll see in today’s headlines.
That’s a powerful combination. It’s also where a lot of homeowners make an expensive mistake. They need cash, they call a lender, and they get talked into refinancing their whole mortgage at today’s rate just to pull out a slice of equity.
I’m Frank Burks II, and I help homeowners across Smyrna, Murfreesboro, and Nashville put their equity to work without giving up what they’ve already got. Here’s how the three main options really compare.
Three Ways to Tap Your Home Equity
Cash-out refinance: You replace your current mortgage with a new, bigger one and take the difference in cash. One loan, one payment, but your entire balance moves to today’s rate.
HELOC (home equity line of credit): A second loan that works like a credit card secured by your home. You draw what you need, when you need it, during a draw period, and you usually pay interest only on what you’ve used. Most HELOC rates are variable and move with the prime rate.
Home equity loan: Also a second loan, but you get a lump sum with a fixed rate and a fixed payment. Think of it as a HELOC’s steady, predictable cousin.
With both a HELOC and a home equity loan, your first mortgage stays exactly where it is.
The Question That Decides It: What’s Your Current Rate?
Here’s an example with round numbers. Say you owe $250,000 at 3.5% and you need $60,000 for a remodel. Your principal and interest on that first mortgage is about $1,123 a month.
Cash-out refinance: a new $310,000 loan at an example rate of 7.25% brings principal and interest to about $2,115 a month. You just added close to $1,000 a month, and most of that is the higher rate on money you already owed.
Keep your first mortgage and add a fixed home equity loan: $60,000 at an example rate of 8.5% over 20 years is about $521 a month. Together with your current $1,123, that’s about $1,643, roughly $470 a month less than the cash-out.
Keep your first mortgage and use a HELOC: interest-only on $60,000 at an example rate of 8.5% is about $425 a month during the draw period, and you only pay on what you actually use.*
The second loan carries a higher rate, but it only applies to the new money. Your low rate keeps working on everything else. For a lot of homeowners right now, that’s the whole ballgame.
When a Cash-Out Refinance Makes Sense
Your current rate is close to today’s rates. If there’s no low rate to protect, one loan with one payment is often cleaner.
You need a large amount. Cash-out can reach deeper into your equity on some programs, and VA cash-out can go further than most for eligible veterans. My VA loan playbook covers it.
You want everything fixed. A single fixed-rate loan means no variable-rate surprises.
You’re paying off high-interest debt, and the math shows real savings even after closing costs. I’ll run that comparison for you side by side.
When a HELOC or Home Equity Loan Makes Sense
Your first mortgage rate is low. This is the big one right now.
You need money over time, like a remodel paid in stages. A HELOC lets you draw as the work gets done.
You need a smaller amount, where refinancing your whole loan would cost more than it’s worth.
You want a fixed payment on the new money. That’s where a home equity loan fits.
Home Equity Options for Every Situation
Through NEXA I have access to home equity programs from a deep bench of wholesale lenders, so the answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. Here’s what’s available today. Approval still depends on your credit, equity, income and property.
Keep Your Rate HELOC
A revolving line that leaves your first mortgage exactly where it is. Draw what you need, when you need it, with interest-only payment options during the draw period.
- Lines from about $5,000 to over $1,000,000
- Up to 90% combined LTV on select programs
- First or second lien options, with fixed or variable rate choices
Self-Employed HELOC
Built for business owners who write off a lot and earn more than their tax returns show. Qualify with 12 months of bank statements, a profit and loss statement, or 1099s instead of tax returns. Lines go up to about $1,000,000. My Self-Employed Mortgage Guide explains how these income options work.
Fixed-Rate Home Equity Loan
One lump sum at closing on a fixed rate, with 10, 20 or 30-year terms. No draws, no rate surprises, and your first mortgage stays put. Loans go up to about $1,000,000, and up to 90% combined LTV on select programs.
Debt Consolidation HELOC
Roll credit cards, personal loans and car notes into one line secured by your home, with the payoffs handled right inside the application. It starts with a soft credit pull to check your options, and the whole process is digital.
Investor Equity Line
Pull equity from a rental to fund your next down payment or a rehab. Some programs qualify on the property’s rent instead of your personal income, allow 2 to 4 units and LLC-owned properties, and leave a first mortgage with a prepayment penalty untouched. Available as a line or a fixed second. Pair it with my DSCR Investor Guide.
Piggyback HELOC for Buyers
Buying and don’t have 20% down? Pair your first mortgage with a second-lien line at purchase. You can skip mortgage insurance, keep your first loan conforming instead of jumbo, and hold onto your savings. Up to 89.99% combined LTV on primary and second homes, with lines up to $750,000. If you’re near the jumbo line, see my Jumbo Loan Guide.
Flexible-Credit Equity Options
When the score isn’t perfect but the equity is real, there are programs that weigh the house more than the history. Select programs start at a 600 credit score, with lower loan amounts at lower scores.
Know the Risks Before You Borrow
Variable rates move. Most HELOC rates follow the prime rate, which follows the Federal Reserve. The Fed raised rates in September 2026, and HELOC payments tied to prime rise when that happens. Ask about rate caps and fixed-rate options.
Your home is the collateral. Every one of these loans is secured by your house. Borrow for things that build value or save you money, not for things that won’t outlast the loan.
Closing costs are real. A cash-out refinance comes with full closing costs. Many HELOCs and home equity loans cost less to open, but compare the terms, fees, and any early-closure charges.
Don’t turn short-term debt into 30-year debt without a plan. Consolidating credit cards can make sense, but only if the cards stay paid off.
Ask your tax advisor. Interest on home equity debt may be deductible in some cases, such as when the money is used to buy, build, or substantially improve your home. Your tax professional can tell you what applies to you.
Smart Ways Homeowners Use Their Equity
Remodels that add value, like kitchens, baths, and additions.
Paying off high-interest debt with a clear plan to stay out of it.
A down payment on an investment property. Pair it with a rental loan that qualifies on rent, not your income. Here’s how DSCR loans work for Tennessee investors.
Building your own home, using equity toward a lot or a down payment. See my guide to one-time close construction loans.
Let’s Protect Your Rate and Put Your Equity to Work
Your equity took years to build. Before you tap it, let’s make sure the way you borrow fits your goals and protects the rate you already have.
Tell me what you’re planning at my loan options page and I’ll run your options side by side: cash-out, HELOC, and home equity loan. Or start your Secure Application and call me at 615.364.5700. Everybody deserves a key, and everybody deserves to keep a good rate.
*Payment examples are for illustration only and are not rate quotes or offers of credit. They show principal and interest only, using hypothetical rates of 3.5% (existing 30-year loan), 7.25% (new 30-year cash-out refinance), and 8.5% (20-year home equity loan or interest-only HELOC). They do not include taxes, insurance, or closing costs. Actual rates, APRs, and terms depend on credit, equity, property, and program. Program availability, loan amounts and combined LTV limits change often and are not guaranteed. HELOC rates are variable and can increase. Not a commitment to lend; all loans are subject to credit approval, underwriting, and property eligibility.